Tuesday, September 30, 2003

Transportation in "The City That Works"

As anyone who lives in Portland can tell you, it's a challenge getting around here. Our street, freeway, and transit system certainly don't reflect a population of 1,572,000 in the metropolitan area.

The Office of Transportation claims: "Portland stands as a national leader in innovative transportation solutions. Planning and constructing solutions to meet the challenges of growth the region faces, while maintaining our economic viability and neighborhood character, requires Transportation to leverage its limited resources to meet the demands of a growing and evolving city."

This is a city with 1 4-lane, 50-mph interstate running north to south through town; 2 interstate bypasses, which vary from 4 to 6 lanes, one of which runs north to south the length of town 5 miles to the east, the other take a tiny circle around downtown before rejoining the interstate.

We've also got two 4-lane freeway-style highways leading east and west from town, to complete the limited access throughways in the Portland area.

As you can probably guess, rush hour on the freeways here lasts from around 6:00 AM until 9:00 PM, with traffic speeds approaching 15 mph during the peak times. Accidents and traffic stops are another problem, since the local "incident response" teams seem to delight in closing entire lanes of traffic for an hour or two when someone stalls out or runs out of gas. When police pull someone over, they often park multiple squad cars along the shoulder, and display full emergency lights and strobes, slowing any traffic passing by to a standstill.

As to surface streets, the city seems to be systematically removing lanes of traffic for bicycle lanes, adding two-way turn lanes the entire length of major thoroughfares, and crippling major arteries in order to add new legs to the local rail system.

Of course, because these actions drive desperate drivers onto side streets, there is a massive program of "traffic calming" in place. Speed bumps, mini-traffic circles, barricades and other devices are constantly being added to deter autos from using side streets for through traffic.

Rail lines for the highly touted MAX system, run east and west from downtown, and next year will run north, stopping just short of crossing the Columbia into Washington (a huge source of commuter traffic). MAX, unknown to many, is not a light-rail system, but is considered heavy rail. Apparently, the city got a deal on the system when it was first started, but is now paying the price in high construction rates for new additions.

A streetcar runs through downtown, from the college to the hospital. As it runs in traffic lanes, however, and goes between two places that don't seem to be actual destinations, it does not seem to be well-used, and its function could be replaced by a few buses for a fraction of the cost.

Buses run frequently along most routes, however, they're bogged down in the same traffic as auto commuters, and when you add in the constant stops, end up taking horrendously long times to travel. Downtown, certain streets have been closed to all but bus traffic, adding to the auto woes, and handicapping businesses along those streets by reducing visibility (even pedestrian traffic is noticeably lighter along the busways, that it is on the auto streets). Several times recently, articles in the local paper have claimed that the city was looking seriously at removing the busways to help those businesses.

Finally, the city is well-known for it's friendliness to bicycle traffic. There are more bike lanes here than in any other North American city, and plans to add even more are constantly on the boards. Monthly protests by bicycle activists shut down bridges to downtown forcing autos to find alternate routes, and enhancing the general atmosphere of transit hostility. Frankly, if the town were 1/8 its current size, had 1/16 its current population, the weather weren't so cold and wet, everyone who commutes in good enough health to bike several miles a day, and no one minded adding an hour or so to their commute each day, biking might be a serious alternative transit method. As it is though, it seems that the bikers have reached a number that is unlikely to increase in the future.

As a case in point, I was working 4-hour shifts at an office that is 13 miles away from my home. Both locations are less than 2 miles from a major highway, and have convenient parking. In Southern California, such a commute would take about 15-20 minutes, or up to 30 minutes on the worst rush hour freeways. Because my shift started at 5:00 pm, and ended at 9:00, my drive to work took 45 minutes to 1 hour, and my drive home took 20-25 minutes. Since the office sponsored a shuttle service to the local transit center, where I could access either buses or the MAX line, I decided to try that method. Checking out the handy transit planner, I discovered that a bus trip to the closest rail station, and a rail trip out to the transit center would take a minimum of 93 minutes. Add to that time spent waiting for the first bus: 0-15 minutes, waiting for the company shuttle: 0-20 minutes, and shuttle transit time: 15 minutes, the grand total one-way trip to work would take: 108-133 minutes. Does spending 3 and a half to 4 and a half hours commuting 26 miles round trip strike anyone else as unreasonable? On a bad day, I'd spend more time commuting than I did working a four hour shift. Suffice it to say... I continued to drive.

As you can probably tell, I've only begun to brush the surface of this topic... Expect to hear more transit woes from this source.

Friday, September 26, 2003

OLCC -- The Oregon Liquor Control Commission

Here in Oregon, the OLCC controls all aspects of liquor sales. In most states, the Liquor Board regulates vendors, and any establishment with a license to sell liquor. Our version of the Liquor board, not only regulates vendors, but is actually a middleman, selling all liquor at a 106% mark-up rate through state-run liquor stores. (All figures taken from the Governor's budget for 2003-2005.) I'm assuming that the reason for this, rests in the post-prohibition laws that were passed all over the country to prevent rampant alcohol abuse.

The policies of the Oregon version, however, put the state in the decidedly odd position of trying to actively encourage alcohol sales. There is a graduated percentage system that specifically rewards "agents" of the OLCC, otherwise known as liquor store managers, for higher volumes of sales. I'm going to go out on a limb here, and guess that this probably contravenes the original purpose of the office.

The incredible mark-up, of course, makes hard liquor purchases very pricey in this state. I've heard many tales of people bringing back cases to stock their home bars when they visit other states. It's easy to see why, when a bottle that would cost $16 in California typically costs $23 or $24 in Portland.

On the regulatory front, one of the most common uses of state Liquor Boards nationwide, is the control of strip clubs, nudie bars, topless clubs, or any other place that tries to combine drinking and undressed entertainment. Of course, Portland has the highest per capita number of strip establishments and strippers in the country... So that's obviously not high on the agenda of the OLCC.

Instead, if you read the budget, the OLCC operates on a biannual amount of $83,468,045, and is projected to bring in over $561,000,000. Um... Does anyone else see a problem with this? Simply by virtue of the fact that alcohol is a "sinful" commodity, or at least it was 100 years ago, the State of Oregon can run a ridiculously mercenary monopoly on the product. Currently, $8,334,110 is earmarked for merchandising and marketing. Over eight million dollars to encourage the residents of Oregon to buy alcohol, from a monopoly on distribution that makes the old break-up of movie distribution, or the recent actions against Microsoft seem down-right consumer-friendly by comparison.

There's even a "priviledge tax" on the sales of alcohol which brings in a sum over $13 million (I'm not sure exactly how much, since they don't break out the part of that which goes back into the OLCC). So, we're not only buying a product which has been ridiculously priced at 106% over cost, but pay a tax which goes back into the same organization (along with nearly $13 million to the Mental Health Drug Services and Alcoholism account and the Wine Advisory Board) on the same product.

So, ultimately, we're left with two choices... Either the State of Oregon's reliance upon half a billion dollars every two years from the monopoly of the alcohol distribution industry is ethically wrong and should be halted, allowing civilian companies to participate and compete in that sector of the economy... Or this method of revenue gathering is right and proper and should continue. In the latter case, I'd go a step further, if monopolizing alcohol distribution is right, why not other markets? Snack food and candy comes immediately to mind. They're admittedly bad for you in immoderation, cause addiction in some to the detriment of their health and well-being, and are not a "staple" of survival. If liquor sales is a business that it's okay for the state to be the sole participant in, why not snack foods and candy? Why not cigarettes, fried foods, or fast food hamburgers?
Who am I?

Just a little background before I get this started. After 20 years lost in Southern California, I moved to Portland, Oregon in order to marry someone I'd known for 18 years. She was born and raised here, and has never considered living anywhere else. For my part, in the three years that I've called Portland home, I've been consistently dumbstruck by the bizarre and nonsensical administrative and political decisions made here, and I've finally decided to go ahead and let off some steam about it.